President proposes K-12 Pell grants
-
- January
- 30
In his state of the union address, President Bush proposed federal education grants for students in grades K-12, calling them Pell Grants for Kids. The program would offer $300 million in scholarships that low-income students could use to attend the school of their choice.
The President’s proposal would give Pell grants to student stuck in public secondary and elementary schools that have failed to meet federal testing benchmarks for five years or that suffer high drop-out rates.
Sounds a lot like a voucher, no?
Pell grants for college last year went out to 5.3 million students, for a total of $14 billion. That’s up from 4.3 million students receiving $8.8 billion at the start of the Bush Presidency, according to the Wall Street Journal.
























Public schools in Westchester and Rockland are among the best in the state. This type of voucher scheme would merely divert funding from public schools to fund the personal choices of a few people. The teachers’ union supports parents making the choice that’s best for their kids. But—like buying bottled water vs. municipal water, or joining a country club instead of playing the town golf course, it’s a personal choice—if you want to send your children to private or religious schools, don’t ask taxpayers to pick up the tab. Finally, another serious concern should be: if we said that a family could use federal money for a “scholarship” to attend a private or religious school, would we as taxpayers have any say in what kind of schools the money is used for? How about a school that preached hate against the United States? Hey, it’s personal choice, right?
Carl,
Thank you for bringing some very serious questions to light in this debate.